Email, cloud & backup
Should info@ be a shared mailbox, a group or a forward?
Most small businesses have a few addresses that aren't one person, like info@, accounts@ or sales@. Too often they're a full user account with a password everyone knows. Microsoft 365 has better options that cost less and are safer. Here's what each one does and how to choose.
The short version
The short version
- Use a shared mailbox when a few people need to read and reply from one address.
- Use a distribution list when an address just needs to reach several inboxes.
- Don't share the password to a licensed info@ account.
- When someone leaves, converting their mailbox to shared keeps their email without a paid licence.
The options
- Shared mailbox. One mailbox, with its own calendar, that several people open from their own accounts.
- Distribution list. An address that copies each message to every member's own inbox.
- Microsoft 365 group. A group address with a shared inbox, calendar and files, which can connect to Teams.
- Mail-enabled security group. Controls access to things like SharePoint sites and can also receive email. You rarely need one for info@.
- Alias or forward. info@ is an extra address on one person's mailbox, or forwards to them. It breaks when that person is away or leaves.
Side by side
| Shared mailbox | Distribution list | Microsoft 365 group | Alias on one mailbox | Licensed info@ user | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Licence | None needed up to 50 GB | Included with Business plans | Included with Business plans | No extra fee | A full user licence |
| Own inbox? | Yes | No, mail goes to each member | Yes, a group inbox | No, it's that person's inbox | Yes |
| Replies come from the shared address? | Yes, with Send As permission | No, from each member's own address | Only if an admin allows it | Depends on the Outlook app | Yes |
| Who sees what | Every member sees the same mailbox | Each member sees their own copy | Members see the group inbox | Only the mailbox owner | Anyone with the password |
| Sent items | Check after setup: depends on the app and settings | In each member's own mailbox | Conversations stay in the group inbox | In the owner's mailbox | One mailbox, no record of who sent |
| Good for | info@, accounts@, reception | Staff announcements, "everyone@" | Project teams, groups over 25 people, outside members | A sole trader | Avoid |
Which to choose
- A few people answer the address and customers should see one name: shared mailbox. This suits most info@, accounts@ and sales@ addresses.
- The address just needs to reach several people, and each replies personally: distribution list.
- More than 25 people need access, or outsiders need to join: Microsoft 365 group. A shared mailbox supports at most 25 users and can't be shared with outside accounts.
- You need to stop people deleting messages: Microsoft 365 group. You can't prevent members deleting mail in a shared mailbox. In a group, only owners can delete any message.
- You work alone: an alias on your own mailbox is fine. Move to a shared mailbox when you hire.
Set up a shared mailbox
You need an Exchange admin role.
1. In the Microsoft 365 admin center, go to Teams & groups > Shared mailboxes. Select Show all if you can't see Teams & groups. 2. Select Add a shared mailbox, enter a name and check the email address. 3. Select Save changes. It can take a few minutes before you can add members. 4. Select Add members to this mailbox, choose the people and select Add.
The mailbox usually appears in members' Outlook after they restart it. It also works in Outlook on the web and the Outlook mobile app.
To create a distribution list instead, go to Teams and groups > Active teams and groups, select Distribution list, then Add a distribution list. Tick the option to allow people outside your organisation to email it if customers will use the address.
Send As or Send on Behalf
Opening a shared mailbox (Full Access) doesn't let someone send from it. They also need one of these:
- Send As: the email looks like it came from the shared mailbox itself, for example "Accounts".
- Send on Behalf: the email shows "Sam on behalf of Accounts".
Send As is usually what you want for info@ and accounts@. Send on Behalf suits cases where customers should see who replied. An admin sets these in the Exchange admin center under Recipients > Mailboxes, then Manage mailbox delegation.
After setup, send a test reply and check which Sent Items folder kept a copy. This depends on the Outlook app and on mailbox settings your admin can change.
Size limit and when you need a licence
A shared mailbox can store up to 50 GB without a licence. When it fills up, it stops sending, then stops receiving and senders get a bounce message. You need an Exchange Online Plan 2 licence on the shared mailbox if:
- it needs more than 50 GB (Plan 2 raises the limit to 100 GB)
- it uses an archive mailbox
- it's placed on litigation hold.
An Exchange Online Plan 1 licence with the Exchange Online Archiving add-on also covers archiving and litigation hold.
Keep sign-in blocked
Every shared mailbox has a user account behind it. Microsoft says to block sign-in for that account and keep it blocked. New shared mailboxes start with sign-in blocked. A mailbox converted from a person's mailbox doesn't: their old password keeps working until you reset it or block sign-in.
To block sign-in, go to Users > Active users, select the account, then Block sign-in. Blocking can take up to 24 hours to take effect, so reset the password too if you need it to stop now.
When someone leaves
Converting a leaver's mailbox to a shared mailbox keeps all their email and calendar items, and lets their manager or replacement open it. This fits into your wider offboarding checklist.
1. Leave the licence on for now. You won't see the convert option without it. 2. Go to Users > Active users, select the person, and on the Mail tab select Convert to shared mailbox, then Convert. 3. Reset the password and block sign-in, so the leaver can't still get in. 4. Add the people who need access as members. 5. If the mailbox is under 50 GB, remove the licence so you stop paying for it.
Don't delete the user account. The shared mailbox needs it. Inbox rules carry over, so check for rules you don't recognise.
Google Workspace equivalents
- Collaborative Inbox. A Google Group that works like a shared mailbox. Members can assign conversations to each other and mark them complete. A group owner turns it on under Group settings > Enable additional Google Groups features. Conversation history must be on. If you can't see Google Groups, your admin needs to turn on Groups for Business.
- Reply as the group. In the group's settings, Who can post as group controls who can send from the group's address. Setting Default sender to the group address suits addresses where many people reply.
- Mail delegation. Lets people open another person's Gmail without the password. An admin turns it on in the Admin console under Apps > Google Workspace > Gmail > User settings > Mail delegation. The admin also chooses whether delegated emails show the owner only, or the owner and the delegate.
Common questions
Does a shared mailbox need its own licence?
Not up to 50 GB. The people who open it need their own licensed mailbox. A licence on the shared mailbox is needed for more storage, an archive or litigation hold.
Can people outside our business use our shared mailbox?
No. Only people in your organisation can be given access. For outside members, use a Microsoft 365 group with guest access turned on.
Should accounts@ be a shared mailbox or a distribution list?
Usually a shared mailbox. Invoices and payment questions then sit in one place, with one reply history that anyone covering can follow.
Can we switch a shared mailbox to a Microsoft 365 group later?
No. Microsoft says a shared mailbox can't be migrated to a Microsoft 365 group, so choose carefully at the start. If you're moving email to Microsoft 365, sort these addresses out as part of the move.
Does a shared mailbox need MFA?
Nobody should sign in to it directly, so block sign-in instead. Each person reaches it through their own account, which should have MFA. Our guide to securing Microsoft 365 covers the settings.
Sources
- Microsoft Learn: About shared mailboxes
- Microsoft Learn: Create a shared mailbox
- Microsoft Learn: Convert a user mailbox to a shared mailbox
- Microsoft Learn: Compare types of groups in Microsoft 365
- Microsoft Learn: Create distribution groups in the Microsoft 365 admin center
- Microsoft Learn: Create a group in the admin center
- Microsoft Learn: Add another email alias for a user
- Microsoft Learn: Prevent user sign-in and block access to Microsoft 365
- Microsoft Learn: Exchange Online service description
- Google Workspace: Make a group a Collaborative Inbox
- Google Workspace: Update a group's settings
- Google Workspace: Let users delegate access to a Gmail account
This guide is general information, not legal or financial advice. If you think you’ve lost money or personal information, contact your bank and the services named above straight away.
Keep reading
Related help
Talk to NovaSoft
Want a hand with this at work?
These guides are free to use. If your business wants help putting the checks, accounts and devices in place, our team can do it with you.
